Black Sheep MKE

  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon

Milwaukee, United States
Restaurant· Brunch restaurant· Lunch restaurant· Meal delivery· Wine bar· Cocktail bar

Black Sheep MKE Reviews | Rating 4.4 out of 5 stars (5 reviews)

Black Sheep MKE is located in Milwaukee, United States on 216 S 2nd St. Black Sheep MKE is rated 4.4 out of 5 in the category restaurant in United States.


216 S 2nd St

Price range



+1 4142230903

Service options

Outdoor seatingKerbside pickupNo-contact deliveryDeliveryTakeawayDine-in


Bar on siteGender-neutral toiletsHigh chairsToilets


Wheelchair-accessible seatingWheelchair-accessible toilet


AlcoholBeerCocktailsCoffeeComfort foodHappy-hour drinksHappy-hour foodLate-night foodOrganic dishesSmall platesSpiritsVegetarian optionsWine

Open hours

Write review Claim Profile



I would first like to say why I am rating this three stars and it’s due to mainly two factors. The food is just good and nothing special along with a lack of flavor in areas where it would be easy to make some. I had the biscuits and gravy and the biscuits were just fine but the gravy lacked any sort of flavor, be it spice or something original in it. The selection of food is very generic to all brunch places making this not much of an experience to remember. We were seated downstairs and most of the tables as wobbly and there is little light down there. I did however like the idea of having a button to call your waiter/waitress when you need something. This made it very easy for when we were ready to order and all. The service from the waitstaff was very good and friendly as well. We got two cups of coffee to go and it was three dollars for a small cup, won’t make that mistake again. I would much rather try other new places in Milwaukee.


Tori Schmitt

We were seated right away in the basement which is a bit dark at certain tables. Our table was wobbly so we informed our waiter and asked to sit at a better table, all good, but I think you would know if your tables are wobbly in a more posh place like this. The service has these buttons they give your table to call your waiter to order or if you need anything. Kind of interesting concept, the waiter came everytime we pressed it, which was minimal. We ordered our food and drinks at the same time and our food came before our drinks, that's where I'm knocking this down one star. I get the bar was backed up, but hold off on sending the food order to the kitchen then. The food was okay, and for the price and the atmosphere I just expected better. That is why I knocked off another star because the food was good but not great. I was really excited for the pancake batter cheese curds and they weren't good. My chicken and waffles were decent. The to go coffee is barely a cup of coffee for 3.


Tony Matoska

Had a fantastic meal with my wife. Food was fantastic and social distancing guidelines very strictly followed


Thomas Long

Great part of town. Drinks are good and creative. Servers have always been attentive, whether it is takeout or dinning in. Cool atmosphere inside. I wish the food was better. I've been here 5-10 times and have ordered a variety of items on the menu, and unfortunately, I've always come away unimpressed.


Heather Tinus

We went last night for my birthday, love how they are set up right now. They recommend reservations. They give you a call button at your table so when you need anything or are ready for putting a order in, you press the call button and the server is there or acknowledges you need them. Such a good idea and we had great service. All of our food was so good, we order appetizers: cheese curds and pretzel (both were so good highly recommend), for dinner the table all ordered: chef's burger, Orecciette, salmon, and cauliflower. Everyone raved about their food. We topped it off with their key lime pie. Cannot say better things. Will be going back.

Top 10 companies in Restaurant category in United States