New City, United States
40 S Main St
$$$
+1 8454992929
N/A
Kerbside pickupDeliveryIn-store pick-upIn-store shoppingTakeaway
Wheelchair-accessible car park
I came in to get cupcakes for a family birthday and a recent passing of a family member who’s life we were celebrating and instead of a cake, we chose some of the outrageously and incredibly delicious cupcakes. We chose many different ones and everyone chose a cupcake starting in birthday order. After everyone chose (many had great difficulty making a choice), we lit candles and sang happy birthday followed by comments including “oh my god, these are amazing, how do we get these on long island, and on and on. The cupcakes are not inexpensive, likely comparable with other places in price but way above in quality and taste. Fortunately I won’t be visiting Caked Up frequently because I could eat everyone and we know how that would go. Fortunately though and seriously, the cupcakes were awesome, everyone loved the presentation and they were delicious so we will definitely recommend Caked Up to anyone asking for or in need of an over the top dessert recommendation!!!! Marc & Dina
like
It was too sweet and it wasn't my taste. I like delicate, high-quality cake with less sweetness like European or Asian style cakes but this is not like that. Today wasn't a good day for me. I felt like having a good cake and looked for a good bakery nearby so we drove extra miles. The girl misheard my husband's order and gave even extra cake and of course, she charged for it. It's overpriced for what it is and I don't know what to do with it. I'm sure a lot of people like their cakes and this is just my opinion.
While the cupcakes are so cute to look at, the taste really isn’t that great. The few that we tried were dry and had a sort of fake bakery taste to them (grocery store bakery quality). I was surprised to see so many positive reviews raving about the taste because it wasn’t anything spectacular.
Amazing how they made the exact cake I imagined just by going back and forth through email and calls. It was also delicious! Highly recommend, their cupcakes are also amazing!
Everything’s pretty good. If you like light desserts def don’t go here. All their frosting is really sweet. Which I like but I could understand why some people don’t like it.
Deli
The best companies in the category 'Deli'