Paul's on Times Square

  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon

New York, United States

paulson42.com
Italian restaurant· Takeout restaurant· Pizza delivery· Bar· Bistro· Pizza restaurant

Paul's on Times Square Reviews | Rating 4.3 out of 5 stars (5 reviews)

Paul's on Times Square is located in New York, United States on 136 W 42nd St. Paul's on Times Square is rated 4.3 out of 5 in the category italian restaurant in United States.

Address

136 W 42nd St

Price range

$$

Phone

+1 2122047246

Service options

Outdoor seatingDeliveryTakeawayDine-in

Amenities

Bar on siteGender-neutral toiletsHigh chairsToilets

Accessibility

Wheelchair-accessible entranceWheelchair-accessible liftWheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

AlcoholBeerCocktailsCoffeeComfort foodHappy-hour drinksHappy-hour foodLate-night foodSmall platesSpirits

Open hours

...
Write review Claim Profile

C

Casey Haynes

Oh my god what an amazing experience!! My best girlfriend and I went here for dinner on our first night in New York and I must say I was thoroughly impressed! Such a beautiful ambiance and location, and the service was phenomenal! They made me a hand crafted Cosmopolitan (for my Sex in the City crave) as well as provided outstanding dishes! The lovely waitress that served us was just amazing and made the experience that much better! I would highly recommend this location and really hope to visit again!

K

Kelly Taylor

Restaurant is cozy and inviting. Servers were very attentive and responsive to our needs. Food was excellent. Antipasto plate and duck confit w truffle oil pizza were excellent. Veal and beef bolognese pasta and orchetti pasta w sausage and repeeni were excellent as well. Creme brulee was delicious. We used a groupon and added dessert and a bottle of wine to make it a to die for meal. I would recommend trying this place for a nice Italian meal.

C

CreativeKid90

The place is within a hotel but the atmosphere of it is pretty nice. I was very welcome dressed casual but only for a takeout, it looked pretty casual/upscale. I ordered a Penne Vodka with Salmon. I’d have to say it was worth the money. I was upset at first with the portion but it turned out pretty tasty.

P

Pierrela Jeanbaptiste

I had a great time here! Fine dining at super reasonable prices. I did the prix fix menu option and chose the Ceasar salad, Follie di Melanzane, and the tiramisu. The star of the show was the main dish Follie di Melanzane. The presentation of the dish was awesome it's literally a show. The dish comes and there's an eggplant sitting in the plate i wondered what's going on then the waiter released the piece de resistance a delicious eggplant based pasta dish I added shrimp. The service was excellent! After a long day of traveling the rough NY streets it's nice to experience friendly professional wait and host staff.

F

Foodlover Girl

We were looking for a pre-theater spot in Midtown, and found this spot. It is located inside Hilton Garden Inn. You had to go down the hall to the elevator, and go up to “Paul’s on Time Square”. The inside was not as big as I expected it to be, but nice and cozy. It is kind of a mix of casual and semi-formal from the look of it. Their complimentary bread were sooo good, it disappeared within seconds! We asked for more, and they brought out twice as much for us. Yum! We ordered Calamari Fritti to share. Since one of us is not a fan of anything spicy, they also gave us regular marinara sauce too, thanks! They were plump and huge portion! We all enjoyed them! For main, we had Branzino Di Chile Piccata, Salmone Alla Cartoccio, and Capellini Ai Frutti Di Mare. Branzino was cooked perfectly, Salmon was packed with flavor, but it could’ve come with a bit more veggies… Seafood Pasta was a nice big portion, with a generous amount of seafood. Filling and satisfying. Since we all enjoyed our meal, we decided to get one dessert to share. We ordered Tartufo to share among the four of us. It was a big hit at the table, everyone enjoyed it! We had a nice dinner here. It was relaxing, never rushed yet everything came out in a timely manner. We had plenty of time to get to our Broadway show. The servers were really friendly and polite, we were very well taken care of. I say it is a bit on pricey side, but it is in midtown…