Casa Benedetto's

  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon

St. Augustine, United States

casabenedettos.com
Italian restaurant· Southern Italian restaurant· Sicilian restaurant

Casa Benedetto's Reviews | Rating 4,6 out of 5 stars (8 reviews)

Casa Benedetto's is located in St. Augustine, United States on 197 Blackford Way. Casa Benedetto's is rated 4.6 out of 5 in the category italian restaurant in United States.

Address

197 Blackford Way

Price range

$$

Phone

+1 9044715999

Service options

Outdoor seatingKerbside pickupTakeawayDine-in

Amenities

Good for kidsHigh chairsToilets

Accessibility

Wheelchair-accessible car parkWheelchair-accessible entranceWheelchair-accessible seatingWheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

AlcoholBeerCoffeeComfort foodHealthy optionsSmall platesVegetarian optionsWine

Best known for
Fresh Sushi
Biggest weakness
Inconsistent service
Most praised
Value for Money
Recommended for
Families, Sushi lovers
Write review Claim Profile

A

Antonio Marshall

Be prepared to be amazed with flavor overload. This place will have u wondering why u went anywhere else. Authentic Italian Restaurant IS Beneath a proper description of this place. If you desire the full experience of a properly prepared meal that will adequately educate your taste buds... This is the place. Michael was the best. Ask for him.

K

Kathy Prorock

Great dining experience! The food was fantastic, authentic italian dining! The eggplant parmesan was the best I have ever had. My husband enjoyed the stuffed pork chop and pasta. The owner, cook and staff were very accommodating and friendly. Highly recommend trying this Saint Augustine dining gem!!

V

Vicki Jo Pollina

Best Italian restaurant in town. Relocated from Vilano Beach to Rt. 1 South behind Walgreens. Intimate European style atmosphere, attentive service from both wait staff and the proprietor. Nice wine list, complimentary authentic Italian bread (best I've ever had) and caponata appetizer; eggplant Parmigiano tender and flavorful with choice of penne pasta or angel hair. Cheesecake was authentic Sicilian delight made with ricotta cheese (better than the usual boring cream cheese versions). My new fave in St. Augustine.

C

Cathy Brewster

This place is a hidden gem. The food was fresh and wonderfully delicious with freshly made pasta and ravioli. Appetizers didn’t disappoint! Michael, our waiter was great with his insight to the menu and he and his assistant checked on us to make sure we were ok and if we needed anything. We sat outside and never felt neglected! We would come as a regular if we lived here!!! We were on vacation traveled from Atlanta,Georgia.

C

Collin Jordan // Enclave Tattoo

Outstanding St. Augustine gem and one of our new favorite fine dining spots when we come to visit. Fantastic home-style Italian food in a cozy setting! My partner is vegan and they went out of their way to accommodate her. If you like Italian food that feels and tastes like it was made just for you look no further. 10/10 would recommend

A

Amber Lane

On vacation with my boyfriend and we always look up the best restaurants in the area and this BEAUTIFUL mom and pop Italian restaurant comes up. My boyfriends Italian and we thought we’d give it a try! It is absolutely amazing! You start off with bread and soup and there pasta is to die for! Topped it off with some red wine. Two vacationers passing through and we loved it and we will be back!️

C

Cindy Stephens

The very best!! Sangria delicious and large serving. Everything fresh and scrumptious with generous portions. Entrees cooked fresh as ordered. I would highly recommend this to anyone who wants quality and value. Wish I lived close enough to get here in a couple hours...I would definitely make the trip!! Service very attentive and helpfu..go try it..I am not wrong about this. I

D

Debbie Staicu-Carter

While vacationing in St Augustine we found this place online and decided to give it a try. This place does not disappoint, we loved the food and the atmosphere.

Popular Topics Mentioned

Open hours