Search Icon

Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon
  • Trustfeed ratings Icon

Cape May, United States

capemaypeanutbutterco.com
Bakery· Takeout restaurant· Dessert· American· Vegetarian Friendly· Retail· Sandwich shop· Nut store

Cape May Peanut Butter Co. Reviews | Rating 4.7 out of 5 stars (8 reviews)

Cape May Peanut Butter Co. is located in Cape May, United States on 516 Carpenters Ln. Cape May Peanut Butter Co. is rated 4.7 out of 5 in the category bakery in United States.

Address

516 Carpenters Ln

Price range

$$$

Phone

+1 6098984444

Service options

Kerbside pickupTakeaway

Amenities

Good for kids

Accessibility

Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings

CoffeeComfort foodQuick bite

Open hours

...
Write review Claim Profile
B

Birderforlife

WOW! Everyone needs to visit this shop when in Cape May. The staff goes out of their way to explain the unique foods they sell. And they make most of it. We recommend getting a sandwich, Honey Roasted PB and Banana on toasted Multi grain bread! Cookie Fries are JUST PERFECT and a tasty Cup of delicious French Press coffee. Everybody working there are kind and courteous. And as the sign out front says, it IS - THE HAPPIEST PLACE IN CAPE MAY! We will be happy to order online.

S

spoorthi Shres

In love with their clean peanut butter chocolate cookies and organic peanut butter with ingredients- Organic peanuts and Love

N

Nolan Doran

I love this place and come here every time I visit Cape May. You have to try the chocolate peanut and the natural peanut butters. They're out of this world!

Z

Zachary Herb

This place is heaven on earth for anyone with at least an occasional peanut butter craving. You’ll find a broad selection of peanut themed snacks packed into a small store. They’ve got a great variety of delicious nut butters, which are available to sample, and an equally impressive selection of jams. The display case is packed with cookies, scones, and my new favorite...the peanut butter cannoli. You’ll also find creative iced teas, peanut butter focused sandwiches, and coffee to counter any subsequent sugar rush. Staff is friendly and helpful. Must-visit!

M

Megan Foster

Just finished my butterscotch peanut butter and wish I had more. So, so good. If you love peanut butter this is the place to go. They have a variety of flavors - chocolate, butterscotch, plain and everything in between. Additionally, they have yummy baked goods and other fun stuff to buy. The shop is small, but cute and fun to browse. Always visit when we go to Cape May

B

Barbara Gallagher

My husband and I took a day trip and of course we had to stop here and pickup some of our favorites. We were very impressed how they handled social distancing. Very organized and sensible.

P

Poppy Robson

Fast, great service. I'm very glad you're open so late during all of this! We're mid move so late night dinners are more common than we'd like to admit. Would have left a positive survey but I didn't get a receipt :c. Keep up the good work!

J

Jordan Winter

I had the sweetest time visiting this place! I was blown away by the customer service - the woman who was working when I was there yesterday on Sunday went above and beyond to show me and other customers what the Peanut Butter Company is all about, and clearly cares about what she does. I had a delicious sandwich with honey roasted peanut butter, bananas, and bacon - absolutely delicious and comforting. Their peanut butter has an incredible taste and texture unlike the typical store-bought type. Loved what I got and can’t wait to return!

Top 10 companies in Bakery category in United States

Close